College of Western Idaho
Addressing
Gender Inequality
In the Work Force
Madison Weston
English 102 - 011W
Leslie Jewkes
March 12, 2013
Abstract
Addressing
gender inequalities in Idaho and in the United States is a current goal,
locally and globally. Promoting gender equality and women empowerment is
necessary for better working relationships and environments. Disempowerment of
women in both Idaho and across the United States is an issue that must be
addressed in order to promote and effect a change; it’s a problem that has
perpetuated across history, because it currently exists both here in Idaho and
across the world, and because without examining biases the issue will never
change. These are the main point that will be discussed and reviewed. Promoting
gender equality and women empowerment should be necessary for better working
environments.
Addressing Gender Inequality
Every
person is familiar with biases; we see, hear and have biased interactions every
day. Globally we are working together, acknowledging the problem of gender
inequality and reaching for the solutions. According to the United Nations
website, our goal is to promote gender equality, and empower women to fight
against discrimination (Department of Public Information). This goal is one of
the eight Millennium Developmental Goals, which all 191 United Nations members
have agreed to try and achieve by 2015(Department of public information).
Promoting gender equality and women empowerment should be necessary for better
working environments. Gender inequalities is not only a global issue, there are
problems with inequality and discrimination here in the U.S. and in Idaho.
Disempowerment
of women in both Idaho and across the United States is an issue that must be
addressed in order to promote and effect a change; it’s a problem that has
perpetuated across history, because it currently exists both here in Idaho and
across the world, and because with out examining biases the issue will never
change.
Inequality Across History
Looking
throughout our past history, we find examples of gender inequalities suggesting
this is not just a current issue. The first acts for Equality Rights began
around 1850; hopes for social, economic, and political gender equality was know
as Feminism (Brunell 2007). The
idea of gender equality due to issues and problems has been dated back to
before the fourteenth and sixteenth centuries. According to author Laura
Brunell, there have been three waves in the acts of feminism (Brunell 2007).
The first wave between 1848 and 1920 “focused primarily on obtaining the full
legal personhood and the political enfranchisement of women (Brunell 2007).”
The second was between 1963 and 1990, this wave also pushed for these goals and
unfortunately lost, yet began the Equal Rights Movement (Brunell 2007).
Resulting from these waves came ideas for women empowerment, the National
Organization of Women, and the civil rights act of 1964 (Brunell 2007). From
past to present gender inequality issues are still a concern and a known factor
for work environments.
Many important woman figures had a role
in the act, and have played into the movement for equal rights. Lucretia Mott
and Susan B. Anthony were two women who led the first wave of action towards
rights of equality with the passing of the 19th amendment (Brunell
2007). Margaret Floy Washburn, and Mary Calkins also had an impact; they
impacted the workforce from their problems with inequalities in the education
system. After Harvard refused Mary Calkins the degree she earned, Washburn
became the first women to receive a psychology PhD (Meyers 2012). According to
David Meyers, in the late 1800’s psychology, like most fields, was a man’s
world (Meyers 2012).
William James helped
break that mold when he accepted Mary Calkins as his student. Although Calkins
went on to outscore all the male students on the Ph.D. exams, Harvard
University denied her a degree. In its place she was told, she could have a
degree from Radcliffe College, Harvard’s sister school for women. Calkins
turned down the offer, but continued her work (Meyers
2012). This is a strong example of how gender biases began with our ancestors’
seed. Through these and similar events inequalities have been passed down
through generations.
Bringing
focus to origin and looking forward to recent events, we think of when gender
biases started and what resulted. According to Laura Brunell 2007, “Feminism
originated in critiques of the ways in which power and autonomy have
historically been denied to women and other people, purely on the basis of who
they are” (Brunell 2007). The third wave is our current wave and the problems
were facing today such as sexism, this third wave began in the 1990’s. Focusing
on positions and unfinished work of the previous wave, third wave activist goals
were setting success examples, battling sexism, and setting awareness of
barriers (Brunell 2007).
These woman and others like them grew up with the expectation
of achievement and examples of female success as well as an awareness of
barriers. They chose to battle sexism by standing sexist symbols on their
heads, to fight patriarchy with irony, to answer violence with stories of
survival, and to combat continued exclusion with grass-roots activism and
radical democracy. Rather then becoming part of the machine, third wavers began
both sabotaging and rebuilding the machine itself. (Brunell 2007)
The problem of gender
inequality has remained an issue through these efforts and others throughout
history. This issue needs to be addressed, the impacts have been damaging, in
means of health, communication, and way of living.
Examining Biases
Why
Examine Biases? How has gender inequalities been so damaging? Because of gender
inequalities, resulted health inequalities between men and women, our
communication towards one another has biases, and our way of living has been
rebuilt around inequalities.
Firstly and according to The International Journal for Equity in Health,
“Gendered practices of working life create gender inequalities through
horizontal and vertical gender segregation in work, which may lead to
inequalities in health between men and women (Elwer 2013).” This is an example
that shows our inequalities when it comes to our work force.
Secondly,
communication is important for any environment. Our working environments rely
on good and quality communication. Being able to communicate effectively and
understand one another helps the environment to run smoothly and error free.
According to Dan O’Hair, and Mary Wiemann, “the labels we choose for our
beliefs affect how we communicate them to others and how others respond… When
we place gender ethnic, class, occupation, and role labels on others, we
sometimes ignore individual differences (O’Hair, Wiemann 2012).” This means
that because of stereotypes and inequalities, we have biases on our
communication, which results in poor communication between another. With bad
communication comes inappropriate behavior; crude, offensive vulgar and profane
language can create uncomfortable and unproductive relationships and work
environments according to an introduction with mass communication (O’Hair,
Wiemann 2012).
Lastly,
when it comes to biases and inequalities affecting our everyday lives, we refer
to work and social environments. Our society has been built based on gender
roles and biases. According to author Eleanor Leacock, “research on the
economic and social activities of women has been shaking up some established
assumptions about society and history (Leacock 1983).” According to Leacock we
need to examine our societies, and understand what is going on, in order to
effect change. In this quote Leacock describes her theory on how to effect a
change.
An effective theory of exchange is necessary for analyzing …
and for interpreting the effects on these societies. Only when genders in
primitive societies are understood… can the full force of capitalist relations
in subverting the labor of women, and therefore transforming the entire
structure of relationships in such societies, be appreciated. Until such time,
the present will continue to support the assumption… that the widespread
normality ideal of men as household heads who provision dependent women and
children reflects some human need or drive. (Leacock 1983)
She ends with a statement
declaring if these things do not change and until they do change, the present
world and future world “will continue to be distorted (Leacock 1983).”
Currently Exists
This
letter from the United Nations secretary general discusses how important it is
to fight inequalities and discriminations against women. Throughout his message
the general talks and asks for other members to recognize and understand and
work together to achieve their common goal. He addresses his message on
Valentines Day saying, “this must be a day of advocacy. It must be a day that
triggers action (Ki Moon 2013).” He addressed in his message they will be
holding the largest assembly to end violence against women and girls. In this
message he gives details of the new ideas to stop gender based violence. (Ki Moon 2013).
Routines
and concerns for gender inequalities have been in our attention, especially
when we refer to the work environments. Idaho has made news regarding gender
inequalities in our work force. There have been articles regarding our Governor
Butch Otter’s Cabinet, how women make less money then the men (Popkey 2012).
Not only is this going on, when it comes to our working environments, Idaho has
a gender gap in physician ranks (Dutton). Along these issues locally, when it
comes to the United States there have been cases of female sales
representatives dealing with gender discrimination (Johnson 2013).
In the
United States we have had several instances concerning gender inequalities when
it comes to our work force and inequalities in pay between male and female
employees. According to EduTube’s chart of female to male ratio of income, and
their chart of seats in parliament, it indicates four gender inequalities
globally. In Figure 1, and Figure 2 these charts show us that not a single
country comes close to gender equality in income (EduTube 2009). Secondly they
indicate women outnumber men in parliament in only one country in the world
(EduTube 2009). They also show us
that wealthier countries do not necessarily have higher gender equality
(EduTube 2009). Lastly these two graphs tell us that a country may do well on
one gender indicator and not as well on another (EduTube 2009).
Through
out my research I have spoke with different people, male and female, in
different careers and have had a chance to ask questions. I spoke with
gentlemen named Jesse, who is a chef at a restaurant in Caldwell. Culinary
fields have been known to be male dominated, so I asked him some questions; I
asked how he felt working with female over males? He replied it depends on how
they are as a worker. I asked him if he had any experiences himself with gender
biases? His response was that not that he can recall. I think this is a good
sign for change to start. From my research with interviews from everyday
workers, I have a gathered a sense that when asked no one portrays to have
gender biases. When trying to reach someone in higher authority it was much
harder to get a response.
Women’s
roles in our current economy have advanced compared to several years ago. Roles
have changed, yet discrimination is still an issue. Disempowerment of women in
both Idaho and across the United States is an issue that must be addressed in
order to promote and effect a change; it’s a problem that has perpetuated
across history, because it currently exists both here in Idaho and across the
world, and because with out examining biases the issue will never change.
Figures 1 & 2
Works Cited
Brunell, Laura. "Feminism Reimagined:
The Third Wave." Annals of American
History. 2008. <http://www.america.eb.com.cwi.idm.oclc.org/america/article?articleId=442878&query=gender
equality>.
Department
of Public Infromation, United Nations. Department of Public Information. UN Web
Services 2010. Web. <http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/>.
Dutton, Audrey. "Idaho
Deals With Gender gap in physician ranks." Idaho Statesman 27 Jan 2013, n. pag. Web. 22
Feb. 2013.
<http://www.idahostatesman.com/2013/01/27/2428077/idaho-still-dealing-with-gender.html
Elwer, Sophia, Lena Alex, and Anne
Hammarstrom. "Gender (in)equality among employees in elder care:
implications for health” International
Journal for Equity in Health. 11.1 (2012): 1-10. Web. 9 Feb. 2013.
Johnson,
Linda A. "Female sales reps: Daiichi Sankyo discriminates." Idaho
Statesman [Trenton]
11 Feb 2013, National Business News. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
Ki Moon, Ban. United Nations.
Department of Public Information. SECRETARY-GENERAL, IN MESSAGE
FOR ‘ONE BILLION RISING’ CAMPAIGN, SEEKS ‘VALENTINE MESSAGE’ FROM GOVERNMENTS
COMMITTING TO END VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN, GIRLS.
New York: News and Media Division, 2013. Web.
<http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2013/sgsm14818.doc.htm>.
Leacock,
Eleanor. "Interpreting the origins of gender inequality: Conceptual and
historical problems." Dialectical
Anthropology. 7.4 (1983): 263-284. Web. 14 Feb. 2013.
<http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF00249543?LI=true>.
Meyers, David G. Psychology in everyday life. New York, NY: 2012.
O'hair, Dan, and Mary Wiemann. "An
introduction with Mass Communication." Real
Communication. Boston: 2012.
Popkey, Dan. "In Gov. Butch
Otter's cabinet, women make less money then men." Idaho
Statesman[Boise] 18 Mar 2012, n. pag. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
<http://www.idahostatesman.com/2012/03/18/2040540/in-otters-cabinet-women-make-less.html
StatPlanet,
EduTube. Ratio of Estimated Female to Male earned income.
2009. Edutube, Australlia. Web. 9 Mar 2013.
<http://edutube.org/en/blog/gender-equality-we-still-have-long-way-go>.
StatPlanet,
EduTube. Percentage of seats in paliament held by women.
2009. Edutube, Australia. Web. 9 Mar 2013.
<http://edutube.org/en/blog/gender-equality-we-still-have-long-way-go>.
Annotated Bibliography
Brunell, Laura.
"Feminism Reimagined: The Third Wave." Annals of American History. 2008.
<http://www.america.eb.com.cwi.idm.oclc.org/america/article?articleId=442878&query=gender
equality>.
This is an article based off the background of feminists
movements based to empower women. This article goes into detail of the first
wave, and second wave and third wave of movements. After discussing the
background information, the author discusses the current movement, called the
third wave. The author talks of the current issues and importance to society.
This article is a recent article written in 2007. The author
has credibility considering the article being in an educational database. The
author cites her sources and does not show bias in her work. Laura Brunell, the
author presents the facts and gives background knowledge for better
understanding.
I
am going to be using this particular article to reference the history of gender
equality issues and to bring forth our current issues. I will be referencing
her facts of the time line of the different movements. Also the relations
between the issues and current issues will be good sources for examples.
Department of Public
Infromation, United Nations. Department of Public Information. UN Web Services
2010. Web. <http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/>.
Dutton , Audrey.
"Idaho Deals With Gender gap in physician ranks." Idaho Statesman 27 Jan 2013, n. pag. Web. 22 Feb. 2013.
<http://www.idahostatesman.com/2013/01/27/2428077/idaho-still-dealing-with-gender.html
This is a
newspaper article I will reference for examples of a women in a locally male
dominated career.
Elwer, Sophia,
Lena Alex, and Anne Hammarstrom. "Gender (in)equality among employees in
elder care: implications for health.." International
Journal for Equity in Health. 11.1 (2012): 1-10. Web. 9 Feb. 2013.
I will reference
gender inequalities in the work environment.
Johnson, Linda A.
"Female sales reps: Daiichi Sankyo discriminates." Idaho Statesman [Trenton] 11 Feb 2013, National Business
News. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
Ki Moon, Ban.
United Nations. Department of Public Information. SECRETARY-GENERAL,
IN MESSAGE FOR ‘ONE BILLION RISING’ CAMPAIGN, SEEKS ‘VALENTINE MESSAGE’ FROM
GOVERNMENTS COMMITTING TO END VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN, GIRLS. New York: News
and Media Division, 2013. Web.
<http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2013/sgsm14818.doc.htm>.
This letter from
the secretary general of public information, I will be using this letter as a
reference to how important the MDG is.
Leacock, Eleanor.
"Interpreting the origins of gender inequality: Conceptual and historical
problems." Dialectical Anthropology.
7.4 (1983): 263-284. Web. 14 Feb. 2013. <http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF00249543?LI=true>.
Referenced for
past facts and cause and effects.
Meyers, David G. Psychology in everyday life. New York,
NY: 2012.
In this Psychology book, it gives background information on
psychologists throughout our history. The first women psychologist had to deal
with gender inequality issues in her professional career. This book is used to
learn the use of the techniques to examine human behavior and reasons for
psychology.
This is an error free credible source used for students in
psychology courses. I will be referencing the first women psychologist as an
example of gender inequalities in the work place.
Nugent, Bridget
R. "Beyond Biases and Barriers: Incorporating Women into International
Clinical Research." Women, Social Policy, and the Law. 6.1 (2012):
1-36. Web. 14 Feb. 2013.
<http://digitalcommons.salve.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1050&context=jift>.
This
article references women roles in a business aspect and discusses the biases
that come with. I will be using this article to reference examples of women in
professional careers and the current problems and concerns.
O'hair, Dan, and
Mary Wiemann. "An introduction with Mass Communication." Real Communication . Boston : 2012.
This book discusses how we communicate. It presents the
reason why we communicate the way we do. It also details the process and ways
of communication. The authors explain the issues with our current communication
efforts; Such as our biases towards race, gender and religions.
I will be referencing the examples of issues with our
communication by means of gender biases.
I will also be discussing and referencing how communication is necessary
for our survival and evolution. It is a current, credible, and error free
source.
Popkey, Dan.
"In Gov. Butch Otter's cabinet, women make less money then men." Idaho Statesman[Boise] 18 Mar
2012, n. pag. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
<http://www.idahostatesman.com/2012/03/18/2040540/in-otters-cabinet-women-make-less.html
This source I
will be using for a reference to gender inequalities in Idaho’s State
government.
StatPlanet,
EduTube. Ratio of Estimated Female to Male earned income. 2009. Edutube,
Australlia. Web. 9 Mar 2013.
<http://edutube.org/en/blog/gender-equality-we-still-have-long-way-go>.
Using chart to
reference ration in gender inequalities
StatPlanet,
EduTube. Percentage of seats in paliament held by women. 2009. Edutube,
Australia. Web. 9 Mar 2013.
<http://edutube.org/en/blog/gender-equality-we-still-have-long-way-go>.
Using chart to
reference ration in gender inequalities
"Un
International Women's Day: Empowering Women--The Key To Achieving The Millenium
Development Goals." Women's
International Network News 29.2 (2003): 4. Academic Search Complete. Web. 14 Feb. 2013.
This article I will be using to reference examples of women
empowerment. This article describes women’s roles in our economy. It talks
about how and why it is important to empower women and promote gender equality.
And goes into detail of the global goal.